The Reddit Read Free
A free read of your brand on Reddit, by Karmatic

Right now there's a thread about your category.
A competitor is named in it. Your brand isn't.

Tell me about your brand and I'll go read Reddit for it. Here's what you get:

  • What your customers are saying about you.
  • The threads your competitors are in (and you're not).
  • What customers are asking for.
  • An actionable comment, written for one real thread.
Robert, Co-founder of Karmatic
RobertCo-founder, Karmatic
Tell me about your brand
I need a brand name to search for.
I need a website, even if it's just a landing page.

This is how I learn your brand well enough to recognize it on Reddit.

Not sure what to write?
Ask any AI assistant: Tell me what [your brand] does in three sentences. Paste the answer here, fix anything it got wrong, and add the two or three brands you lose deals to. Takes about thirty seconds.
Forty characters minimum. The thinner this is, the thinner your read.
Want to name your competitors yourself?

I'll work them out from what you wrote above, and I'll email you the list before anything runs so you can correct it. Or name up to five here.

Press Enter or comma after each one. 0 of 5
That email doesn't look right. Check it and try again.

You'll get a quick confirmation email first. Confirm it and I get to work. Your read lands in your inbox when it's done.

Check your email.

I've sent you the competitors I plan to search. Correct anything I got wrong, then hit confirm and I'll start reading. Nothing runs until you do.

Why this matters

Your buyers are asking each other, not you.

When someone is deciding between you and three competitors, they don't read your website. They search Reddit, because they want an answer from a person who already bought the thing and has no reason to flatter anyone. Those threads outrank your marketing, and they're increasingly what AI assistants read before answering questions about your category.

Most brands have never read them.

How the read works

Two minutes from you.
Then I go to work.

Step 1
You write the brief

What you sell and who you're up against. I turn it into a search plan and email it to you to confirm.

Step 2
I search all of Reddit

Your brand, your competitors and your category's language, across all of Reddit rather than a fixed list of communities.

Step 3
I verify every mention

Each result gets read to confirm it's really about your brand, not a coincidental word match. Most tools skip this.

Step 4
I read the threads

The comments inside the conversations where people are choosing what to buy, not just the headlines above them.

Step 5
Your read arrives

A private link in your inbox: a few minutes to read, ending at the one conversation most worth entering.

A promise about the numbers: every number in your read is a real count from threads I actually read. If something can't be measured honestly, it isn't in your read. No rounding, no estimates. That's also why there are no stats on this page: I haven't read your brand yet.
The part nobody else does

Everyone tells you to engage.
Nobody hands you the first draft.

When there's a thread worth entering, the read ends at one real conversation with a comment already drafted for it, your affiliation disclosed, and at least one honest line about where you're not the right fit, because that's what makes the rest credible.

When there isn't one, I tell you that instead of inventing one. And it's a first draft, not a script. The last edit is yours.

The thread · from a real read for a privacy-first analytics tool
r/webanalytics
Do I actually need server-side tracking for a small content site?
2 days ago · 34 comments
Everyone keeps telling me to set up server-side tracking, but the setup looks like a part-time job. Is it actually worth it?
If you run paid ads, yes. Otherwise probably overkill, but curious what others here use.
The comment, drafted for it Ready for your edit

If paid ads are your main thing, honestly, go server-side. Browsers keep blocking client-side scripts and nothing fully replaces it for attribution yet.

But if what you actually want is to know where your traffic comes from and which pages people read, you don't need the pipeline. A privacy-first tool does that with no cookies, no consent banner, and basically no setup. Full disclosure, I work on one, so weigh that however you want.

Short version: server-side if you live and die by ad numbers, something lightweight if you just want clean stats without the compliance headache.

Why this thread

Notice the order: it concedes the competitor is the better answer first, and names exactly where this product is the wrong choice. That's what buys the middle paragraph its credibility, and it is the opposite of how a brand usually writes.

And what I won't do

Nothing gets posted by me, ever. The read tells you plainly what to check about your own account first, because whether a comment lands depends on things I can't see from outside it.

What arrives

Your brand on Reddit,
demystified.

Not a scorecard. An argument, with the threads that produced it one click away.

What people actually say about you

Sentiment inside your own community set against sentiment everywhere else, because the gap between those two numbers usually says more than either one alone. If there isn't enough to measure honestly, I describe rather than quantify.

The threads you weren't in

Real conversations where a competitor got named and you didn't, plus what repeats across them. Always bounded to the threads I actually read, never extrapolated into a claim I can't stand behind.

What your category keeps asking for

The unmet needs and live arguments in your category's communities, whether or not your brand comes up in any of them. This is the part that doesn't depend on anyone having heard of you, which is why it's often the most useful thing in the read.

The words your buyers use

How your communities actually talk: the phrases that repeat, the shorthand your brand has become, the word people reach for instead of the one you'd have chosen. Positioning intelligence you can't get from a survey.

The one thread worth entering, and a comment for it

The single conversation most worth entering, why that one, and a first draft written for it. Plus what to check about your own account before you post anything, because that part I can't see from outside. If nothing in your category is worth entering right now, I say so rather than picking something.

r/yourcategory
What's everyone actually using for this in 2026?
1 day ago · 60 comments
Been running Competitor A for two years now, no complaints.
Depends on budget. Competitor B is cheaper and does most of it.
Second Competitor A, especially if you need the integrations.
Honestly whichever one your team will actually use.
Your brand, not mentionedAcross every comment read
Real reads

Two real reads.
Nothing changed except the names.

Every number below was measured on a real brand. The names are gone because these are real companies that didn't ask to be discussed in public. Yours is private to you, on a link only you get.

your private link
Reddit Read · an activewear brand7 min read
Their fans are warm, but only inside their own room.
Inside their own communities, 48.3% of 89 classified mentions are positive. Outside them, that drops to 23.5%. The warmth is real. It just doesn't travel.
1Inside your community
Their customers gather in four communities on Reddit, not one. I counted all of those as inside, and compared how people talk about them in them with everywhere else. The people in those communities chose to be there. The wider conversation is where undecided people are listening.
Vocal Fans, Talking Only to Each Other
Inside their own communities89 classified mentions
48.3%37.1%
Everywhere else51 classified mentions
23.5%68.6%
Positive
Neutral
Mixed
Negative
Main takeaway
The people most likely to argue their case aren't in the threads where their competitors are getting named instead.

Inside their own communities, nearly half the mentions are positive. That's earned, and it's also expected. These are people who chose to join a space about the brand, so the warmth is concentrated among people who already picked them.

Outside those communities, positive mentions drop by half. The bigger figure is the neutral share. Neutral means someone named the brand in passing, often in a list of other brands, without saying anything good or bad about it. Those people haven't been given a reason to feel anything yet.

The evidence
68.6%
of the 51 times this brand came up outside its own communities, nobody was praising it or complaining about it. They just mentioned it and moved on.
2Where you missed out
I read threads where people in the category asked for recommendations, compared brands or reviewed products, then checked which brands got named. These are the ones a competitor appeared in and they didn't.
One Competitor Named in 3 of the 4 Threads They Missed
Main takeaway
When someone asks what to wear, the biggest name in the category is the one they leave with, because this brand's fans aren't in those threads to offer a different one.

This brand wasn't named in 8 of the 13 category threads I read. A competitor was named in 4 of those 8. The biggest name in the category was named in 3 of those 4, and a second competitor in 1.

What makes that hard to shrug off is the range. Two were people talking through what they actually wear, one was someone asking what to buy, and one was an opinion thread about what the category is missing. When people ask which fabrics and fit features are worth paying for, this brand's fans know the answer. They aren't in those threads to give it.

The 4 threads where a competitor was named and they weren't
The evidence
4 of 13
threads I read named a competitor and never mentioned this brand.
and five more sections
your private link
Reddit Read · a functional drinks brand2 min read
Nobody on Reddit is talking about them yet. Nobody is talking about their competitors either.
Two mentions in 90 days of searching. In the 21 category threads I read, no brand was named at all. That's not a crowded room shutting them out. It's an open one.
1What your category wants
Their category is functional drinks and daily hydration. I read the wider conversations and pulled out what people keep asking for and complaining about, whether or not the brand was mentioned in any of them. Think of it as free customer research.
Two Arguments Keep Coming Back, and No Brand Is Attached to Either
Main takeaway
Their category is telling them what to make and what people distrust, and nobody in those threads is hearing it from a brand.

Across 435 comments in 21 threads, two things came up again and again. People want magnesium in an everyday drink, not the sodium load built for athletes. And people are tired of being sold a daily habit they have no reason to need. Neither conversation has a brand in it, which is rare for a category this crowded on the shelf.

Unmet need
Magnesium over sodium for everyday use
People keep saying the high-sodium mixes were made for athletes, not for them. Magnesium is the word that comes up when they describe what they'd want instead.
Where I found it
r/biohackersMaybe daily hydration needs less salt and more magnesium
r/ultramarathonHow do you handle hydration during ultras?
r/fastingWhat electrolyte mix do you use
Live debate
Wellness rituals versus real need
People are calling out influencers for selling a daily supplement habit to people with no reason to have one. The skepticism is pointed, and it's the most upvoted position in these threads.
Where I found it
r/influencerloungePromoting a DAILY electrolyte powder. This is dangerous marketing.
r/fundiesnarkuncensoredShilling magic supplements, but maybe water and protein is the thing that works?
The evidence
435
comments I read across 21 category threads. No brand was named in any of them.
2What I can't see from outside
Everything above came from public Reddit data. These are the things I can't see from outside, and all of them concern the account they'd post from.
Three Things I Can't See From Outside Their Account

The reading tells me where the conversations are and what's missing from them. It doesn't tell me three things that change the order I'd do everything in.

Whether their account is allowed to post in these communitiesTwo of them want a minimum posting history before a comment stays up. I can't see where an account stands from outside.
How the account looks to Reddit's filtersNew accounts are treated differently, and an account that's had a comment removed carries that forward. A connected account shows me either.
How many hours a week they can give thisTwo hours a week and five hours a week are different plans, and I'd start in a different community for each.

This is the read most brands get, and it's often the more useful of the two. Nothing to defend, and a list of things your category keeps asking for, in the words people use to ask.

Straight answers

Four things I want to be straight about.

It runs once.

This is a read, not monitoring. Nothing watches your brand afterward unless you decide you want that.

It never posts.

Not to Reddit, not anywhere. I hand you a draft and stop there.

It's not a mention counter.

The counts are context for an argument, not the point of it.

It's not a guarantee of findings.

Some brands genuinely have little on Reddit. When that's true, the read says so and turns to your category instead.

FAQ

Questions people ask

Yes, and there's no card and no login. It's the clearest way I know to show what Karmatic does, so I'd rather spend the work and let the read speak for itself. Some people who get one become customers. Most don't, and that's fine.

Because anything instant is a template. I read the threads themselves and check that every mention is really about you, which takes about an hour, longer when other reads are queued ahead of yours.

I send you two things: the confirmation, and your read. Nothing is sold or shared. Unsubscribe in one click and I'll stop.

It's how I learn your brand well enough to recognize it in a conversation, including the ones where people describe you without using your name. It also shapes who I compare you against. A thin description produces a thinner read.

Handled. Every result gets checked to confirm it's about your brand rather than the word, which is why a real description matters more than it looks. A brand called Recess doesn't get credited for people taking one.

No. Never. You get a draft and a note on what to check first. What you do with it is entirely yours.

Find out what the room says
when you're not in it.

Get my Reddit Read

Free. No card. No login. One email to confirm, one when it's ready.